popov/gogo2
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

cleanup, CNN fixes

Browse Source
This commit is contained in:
Dobromir Popov
2025-07-05 00:12:40 +03:00
parent ce8c00a9d1
commit 5ca7493708
18 changed files with 587 additions and 5181 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

303
MODEL_IMPLEMENTATIONS_ANALYSIS_REPORT.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,303 @@
# Model Implementations Analysis Report
*Generated: 2024-12-19*
## Executive Summary
This report analyzes all model implementations in the gogo2 trading system to identify valuable concepts and architectures before cleanup. The project contains multiple implementations of similar models, some unused, some experimental, and some production-ready.
## Current Model Ecosystem
### 🧠 CNN Models (5 Implementations)
#### 1. **`NN/models/cnn_model.py`** - Production Enhanced CNN
- **Status**: Currently used
- **Architecture**: Ultra-massive 256+ channel architecture with 12+ residual blocks
- **Key Features**:
- Multi-head attention mechanisms (16 heads)
- Multi-scale convolutional paths (3, 5, 7, 9 kernels)
- Spatial attention blocks
- GroupNorm for batch_size=1 compatibility
- Memory barriers to prevent in-place operations
- 2-action system optimized (BUY/SELL)
- **Good Ideas**:
- ✅ Attention mechanisms for temporal relationships
- ✅ Multi-scale feature extraction
- ✅ Robust normalization for single-sample inference
- ✅ Memory management for gradient computation
- ✅ Modular residual architecture
#### 2. **`NN/models/enhanced_cnn.py`** - Alternative Enhanced CNN
- **Status**: Alternative implementation
- **Architecture**: Ultra-massive with 3072+ channels, deep residual blocks
- **Key Features**:
- Self-attention mechanisms
- Pre-activation residual blocks
- Ultra-massive fully connected layers (3072 → 2560 → 2048 → 1536 → 1024)
- Adaptive network rebuilding based on input
- Example sifting dataset for experience replay
- **Good Ideas**:
- ✅ Pre-activation residual design
- ✅ Adaptive architecture based on input shape
- ✅ Experience replay integration in CNN training
- ✅ Ultra-wide hidden layers for complex pattern learning
#### 3. **`NN/models/cnn_model_pytorch.py`** - Standard PyTorch CNN
- **Status**: Standard implementation
- **Architecture**: Standard CNN with basic features
- **Good Ideas**:
- ✅ Clean PyTorch implementation patterns
- ✅ Standard training loops
#### 4. **`NN/models/enhanced_cnn_with_orderbook.py`** - COB-Specific CNN
- **Status**: Specialized for order book data
- **Good Ideas**:
- ✅ Order book specific preprocessing
- ✅ Market microstructure awareness
#### 5. **`training/williams_market_structure.py`** - Fallback CNN
- **Status**: Fallback implementation
- **Good Ideas**:
- ✅ Graceful fallback mechanism
- ✅ Simple architecture for testing
### 🤖 Transformer Models (3 Implementations)
#### 1. **`NN/models/transformer_model.py`** - TensorFlow Transformer
- **Status**: TensorFlow-based (outdated)
- **Architecture**: Classic transformer with positional encoding
- **Key Features**:
- Multi-head attention
- Positional encoding
- Mixture of Experts (MoE) model
- Time series + feature input combination
- **Good Ideas**:
- ✅ Positional encoding for temporal data
- ✅ MoE architecture for ensemble learning
- ✅ Multi-input design (time series + features)
- ✅ Configurable attention heads and layers
#### 2. **`NN/models/transformer_model_pytorch.py`** - PyTorch Transformer
- **Status**: PyTorch migration
- **Good Ideas**:
- ✅ PyTorch implementation patterns
- ✅ Modern transformer architecture
#### 3. **`NN/models/advanced_transformer_trading.py`** - Advanced Trading Transformer
- **Status**: Highly specialized
- **Architecture**: 46M parameter transformer with advanced features
- **Key Features**:
- Relative positional encoding
- Deep multi-scale attention (scales: 1,3,5,7,11,15)
- Market regime detection
- Uncertainty estimation
- Enhanced residual connections
- Layer norm variants
- **Good Ideas**:
- ✅ Relative positional encoding for temporal relationships
- ✅ Multi-scale attention for different time horizons
- ✅ Market regime detection integration
- ✅ Uncertainty quantification
- ✅ Deep attention mechanisms
- ✅ Cross-scale attention
- ✅ Market-specific configuration dataclass
### 🎯 RL Models (2 Implementations)
#### 1. **`NN/models/dqn_agent.py`** - Enhanced DQN Agent
- **Status**: Production system
- **Architecture**: Enhanced CNN backbone with DQN
- **Key Features**:
- Priority experience replay
- Checkpoint management integration
- Mixed precision training
- Position management awareness
- Extrema detection integration
- GPU optimization
- **Good Ideas**:
- ✅ Enhanced CNN as function approximator
- ✅ Priority experience replay
- ✅ Checkpoint management
- ✅ Mixed precision for performance
- ✅ Market context awareness
- ✅ Position-aware action selection
#### 2. **`NN/models/cob_rl_model.py`** - COB-Specific RL
- **Status**: Specialized for order book
- **Architecture**: Massive RL network (400M+ parameters)
- **Key Features**:
- Ultra-massive architecture for complex patterns
- COB-specific preprocessing
- Mixed precision training
- Model interface for easy integration
- **Good Ideas**:
- ✅ Massive capacity for complex market patterns
- ✅ COB-specific design
- ✅ Interface pattern for model management
- ✅ Mixed precision optimization
### 🔗 Decision Fusion Models
#### 1. **`core/nn_decision_fusion.py`** - Neural Decision Fusion
- **Status**: Production system
- **Key Features**:
- Multi-model prediction fusion
- Neural network for weight learning
- Dynamic model registration
- **Good Ideas**:
- ✅ Learnable model weights
- ✅ Dynamic model registration
- ✅ Neural fusion vs simple averaging
### 📊 Model Management Systems
#### 1. **`model_manager.py`** - Comprehensive Model Manager
- **Key Features**:
- Model registry with metadata
- Performance-based cleanup
- Storage management
- Model leaderboard
- 2-action system migration support
- **Good Ideas**:
- ✅ Automated model lifecycle management
- ✅ Performance-based retention
- ✅ Storage monitoring
- ✅ Model versioning
- ✅ Metadata tracking
#### 2. **`utils/checkpoint_manager.py`** - Checkpoint Management
- **Good Ideas**:
- ✅ Legacy model detection
- ✅ Performance-based checkpoint saving
- ✅ Metadata preservation
## Architectural Patterns & Good Ideas
### 🏗️ Architecture Patterns
1. **Multi-Scale Processing**
- Multiple kernel sizes (3,5,7,9,11,15)
- Different attention scales
- Temporal and spatial multi-scale
2. **Attention Mechanisms**
- Multi-head attention
- Self-attention
- Spatial attention
- Cross-scale attention
- Relative positional encoding
3. **Residual Connections**
- Pre-activation residual blocks
- Enhanced residual connections
- Memory barriers for gradient flow
4. **Adaptive Architecture**
- Dynamic network rebuilding
- Input-shape aware models
- Configurable model sizes
5. **Normalization Strategies**
- GroupNorm for batch_size=1
- LayerNorm for transformers
- BatchNorm for standard training
### 🔧 Training Innovations
1. **Experience Replay Variants**
- Priority experience replay
- Example sifting datasets
- Positive experience memory
2. **Mixed Precision Training**
- GPU optimization
- Memory efficiency
- Training speed improvements
3. **Checkpoint Management**
- Performance-based saving
- Legacy model support
- Metadata preservation
4. **Model Fusion**
- Neural decision fusion
- Mixture of Experts
- Dynamic weight learning
### 💡 Market-Specific Features
1. **Order Book Integration**
- COB-specific preprocessing
- Market microstructure awareness
- Imbalance calculations
2. **Market Regime Detection**
- Regime-aware models
- Adaptive behavior
- Context switching
3. **Uncertainty Quantification**
- Confidence estimation
- Risk-aware decisions
- Uncertainty propagation
4. **Position Awareness**
- Position-aware action selection
- Risk management integration
- Context-dependent decisions
## Recommendations for Cleanup
### ✅ Keep (Production Ready)
- `NN/models/cnn_model.py` - Main production CNN
- `NN/models/dqn_agent.py` - Main production DQN
- `NN/models/cob_rl_model.py` - COB-specific RL
- `core/nn_decision_fusion.py` - Decision fusion
- `model_manager.py` - Model management
- `utils/checkpoint_manager.py` - Checkpoint management
### 📦 Archive (Good Ideas, Not Currently Used)
- `NN/models/advanced_transformer_trading.py` - Advanced transformer concepts
- `NN/models/enhanced_cnn.py` - Alternative CNN architecture
- `NN/models/transformer_model.py` - MoE and transformer concepts
### 🗑️ Remove (Redundant/Outdated)
- `NN/models/cnn_model_pytorch.py` - Superseded by enhanced version
- `NN/models/enhanced_cnn_with_orderbook.py` - Functionality integrated elsewhere
- `NN/models/transformer_model_pytorch.py` - Basic implementation
- `training/williams_market_structure.py` - Fallback no longer needed
### 🔄 Consolidate Ideas
1. **Multi-scale attention** from advanced transformer → integrate into main CNN
2. **Market regime detection** → integrate into orchestrator
3. **Uncertainty estimation** → integrate into decision fusion
4. **Relative positional encoding** → future transformer implementation
5. **Experience replay variants** → integrate into main DQN
## Implementation Priority
### High Priority Integrations
1. Multi-scale attention mechanisms
2. Market regime detection
3. Uncertainty quantification
4. Enhanced experience replay
### Medium Priority
1. Relative positional encoding
2. Advanced normalization strategies
3. Adaptive architecture features
### Low Priority
1. MoE architecture
2. Ultra-massive model variants
3. TensorFlow migration features
## Conclusion
The project contains many innovative ideas spread across multiple implementations. The cleanup should focus on:
1. **Consolidating** the best features into production models
2. **Archiving** implementations with unique concepts
3. **Removing** redundant or superseded code
4. **Documenting** architectural patterns for future reference
The main production models (`cnn_model.py`, `dqn_agent.py`, `cob_rl_model.py`) should be enhanced with the best ideas from alternative implementations before cleanup.